Eyewitness News asked Merrie Harris, "Would you do this again?"
"Totally," Harris said.
What Harris did certainly had New Yorkers talking.
"Honestly I have to wonder how drunk she was," said Manhattan resident, Andy Hickmott
Merrie said it wasn't alcohol, just her faith, in a homeless man who approached her on Kenmare Street.
It happened while she was heading out to a restaurant with friends.
He wanted money for Vitamin Water and she had no cash.
So, she offered him her American Express Platinum card.
"He said, 'Do you mind if I borrow it?' I looked at him and he seemed so honest," Harris said.
She says he then asked if he could use it to buy a pack of cigarettes too, and she said yes.
The homeless man then proceeded to disappear for a while, during which time, Merrie's friends continued to poke fun at her, and she even began to have a few doubts.
"And everyone around me was just saying, 'you are nuts, that was the dumbest thing to do'" Harris said.
But, the man returned with her card 15 minutes later.
"I said, 'I'm so glad you came back'. I said, 'I knew you would." Harris said.
The man said, "I'm a really honest person."
Merrie's point in all of this is that sometimes if we just have faith in humanity, they will prove us right.
Some New Yorkers say that sounds good.
"I am inspired by the situation and maybe I could reach a point where I could do that for someone, but not today," said Upper West Side resident, Steven Jean.
Merrie may be kind, but she is not stupid.
She called American Express just to be sure and it turns out all the man bought at the Duane Reade was cigarettes and Vitamin Water.
"If you give, it's not going to be a bad thing," Harris said.
Turns out, giving someone a little "credit", at least in this case, paid off.