The income threshold for the new affordable units at Leisure Terrace disqualified some residents from being able to continue to live there. They were penalized in essence for making too much money. But others were thrilled to move into a hard-to-find affordable apartment.
[Ads /]
New patio doors and windows, solar and seismic upgrades, refurbished kitchens and baths -- 68 units at this Hayward apartment complex got a face lift funded by state tax credits design to create quality affordable housing for families making less than $74,000 a year.
RELATED: Bay Area housing prices: A look at the outrageous numbers
Tiavana Havili feels lucky and blessed to have found a place like this.
"We have two kids, so it's just better they have their bedroom and we have ours," she said.
But there were also unlucky families in this story of creating affordable housing. Who was caught in the middle?
"If I could pinpoint the population of people, it would be the folks who aren't necessarily low income and are not necessarily middle class. They're right there in that gap," said Hayward City Councilman Mark Salinas.
Booted out were some teachers, some seniors and grocery store clerks -- some of them making $80,000 to $90,000 a year. They had to move and pay more for less space.
[Ads /]
The president of reliant group, the company that owns the apartments outlined the dilemma they face.
RELATED: Finding affordable housing especially difficult for homeless veterans
"Unfortunately there were many people at Leisure Terrace who were overqualified. But the people at the lowest end of the economic spectrum at 50 to 60 percent of area median income, we need to give them a voice at the table and that's why we used this program called the low income housing tax credit to benefit these people. "
"We are looking at the future at what we could do differently to try to avoid this. And one of the things is to lobby our state representatives to look at the law itself," said Hayward Mayor Barbara Halliday,
The displaced families, about 20 of them, were offered incentives to help them relocate and pay for security deposits and even first months rent. Now, Hayward has 68 additional dedicated affordable housing units. But it's a reminder that in the Bay Area it all depends on how "affordable" is defined and who can "afford" to lose out.