The highway shut down at 3 a.m. from upper SR-35 to Pilarcitos Creek Road.
MORE: Sinkhole temporarily closes Oakland Zoo until at least Jan. 17
The sinkhole formed at a spot where there was a dip that caused the road to close on Thursday, before reopening.
CHP says it is unknown when the highway will reopen. Currently, anyone going to Half Moon Bay will have to drive on Highway 1.