But Little League International CEO Stephen D. Keener would not budge, telling Mayor Rahm Emanuel that as difficult as the decision was and as tough as it has been emotionally on the children and their families, the decision by the organization's charter committee was final, according to the organization's spokesman.
The organization announced Wednesday that Jackie Robinson West had been stripped of its title because team officials falsified boundaries so they could add ineligible players to the roster and that the officials then scrambled to persuade surrounding leagues to go along with what they'd done.
Little League International spokesman Brian McClintock would not detail the conversation between Keener and Emanuel. But the Chicago mayor's office said that during the 10-minute call, first reported in the Chicago Sun-Times, Emanuel suggested alternative punishments could apply, including banning the league from playing for a certain period of time.
The decision has turned the young players into "perpetrators when they are victims," Emanuel said, according to his office.
Although McClintock said the decision is final, in Chicago, where the march of the all-black team from the city's South Side was one of the most heartwarming stories in recent memory, angry community activists made it clear that the fight to give the boys back their championship at the Little League World Series is not over.
"We are asking a law group to look into this, to investigate, because we are hearing from folks all over the country that the [boundary] standards that Jackie Robinson West is being held to is not being held to by other teams across the United States," said the Rev. Michael Pfleger, a prominent activist and Catholic priest on the city's South Side.
An attorney for the Jackie Robinson West program said the team still considers itself national champion and is not ready to give up the title.
"I'm taking the position, and I think they should take the position, that they are still champions unless and until we find out there was a fair process that was even-handed," attorney Victor Henderson said.
Jackie Robinson West officials emphasized that they have not received any written notice that their championship is being vacated. Henderson told reporters that he will be digging into the Little League decision.
"We're going to take our time, we're going to learn the facts, we're going to find out what rules were at play," he said.
Jackie Robinson West officials, whom Little League International either suspended or insisted not be allowed to remain in positions of authority, were expected to speak at a news conference at a downtown law firm scheduled for Thursday afternoon.
On Wednesday, parents of the players and others expressed outrage that such an inspirational championship was being taken from the team of boys aged 11 to 13 years. And one after another, they said Little League International was punishing the boys for something they had no hand in. Little League International has stressed there is no evidence that the boys were complicit in the scheme but that the adults in positions of authority clearly violated the rules.
Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.
Little League CEO On Jackie Robinson West Punishment
Little League International president and CEO Stephen D. Keener discusses Chicago-based Jackie Robinson West's violations, which led to it being stripped of the U.S. championship.
Little League Strips Chicago Team Of U.S. Title
Karl Ravech discusses Little League Baseball's decision to strip the U.S. championship from Chicago-based Jackie Robinson West and suspend its coach for violating a rule prohibiting the use of players who live outside the team's geographic area.