"Our peace has definitely been broken. My heart is hurting. But I am thankful, and I'm grateful to be alive," Toland said.
The Atlanta-based couple was in Oakland over the weekend to celebrate Toland's grandmother's 91st birthday. But just hours before the party, the pair was robbed at gunpoint while walking to their car near Jack London Square.
"I still see the guns. The only thing I was waiting on was the shot. I knew that Saturday was going to be the day that I died," Toland said.
VIDEO: Oakland police chief gives update on investigation into string of armed robberies over weekend
Stallworth says as he and his wife were walking out of a restaurant around 1 p.m., they suddenly found themselves surrounded by three men.
Two of them had guns pressed against Toland's head.
"To me it was egregious to be in broad daylight and you pull up when people just walking around, you know, having a good time," Toland said.
The Stallworths say, between the two of them, the thieves stole around $40,000 worth of goods.
EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: 70-year-old Asian woman describes emotional battle following violent Oakland robbery
Items included cash they had for their trip, Regina's purse and Toland's jewelry.
However, in spite of the loss, Toland tells ABC7 News he was determined not to let it ruin the reason he came into town in the first place -- his grandmother.
"Those guys took a lot of items from me, but they left me with my life and that was the most beautiful thing was able to still show up at that party," Toland said.
An Atlanta couple was in town for their grandmother’s 91st birthday. Just hours before the party, they were robbed at gunpoint in Jack London Square. The experience has left them traumatized and they say they’ll never visit the Bay Area again. Story at 11 @abc7newsbayarea pic.twitter.com/e1vkKPpIbj— Tim Johns (@tim_johns_) May 2, 2022
But it's not just the personal loss and trauma the experience has caused them. The Stallworths say it's also left them with a negative view of the Bay Area.
Toland says he had heard before arriving about crime-related problems in Oakland. After becoming the victim of one himself, he's urging city leaders to do more to keep visitors and residents safe.
"You don't have adequate security or policing. You don't have surveillance. You don't have cameras. And, not only that, your laws are so strict that if you're not going to protect us, you're not even going to allow me to protect myself," Toland said.
Those sentiments were also echoed by his wife, Regina, who says she would hesitate to ever visit the Bay Area again.
VIDEO: 65% of Bay Area residents say fear of crime keeps them from visiting big city downtowns
"I love the city, it's beautiful. But, with what happened to us, I can't come back," she said.
But, the couple notes, despite the traumatic experience, they were moved by the outpouring of support they received from others nearby.
They say one man in particular stayed with them for hours after the incident to make sure they were OK.
"We had people come up to us, placing money in our hand, telling us they're sorry for what happened, and they don't want us to have that impression of their city," Regina said.
Now, as the couple gears up to head home, they say they don't know what the future holds.
They just plan to take it one day at a time.
"Everything has been violated. My peace, my heart, you know, and me personally I don't know what to expect when I get back home," Toland said.