San Francisco police say brakes working on tour bus that crashed in Union Square

EMBED </>More News Videos

ABC7 News has learned San Francisco police have ruled out mechanical failure as the cause of last November's tour bus crash in Union Square that injured 20 people. (KGO-TV)

After a four month investigation, San Francisco police say it was likely driver' error that led to the tour bus collision that injured some 20 people last fall at Union Square.

Investigators said they could find no skid marks and the double decker had no mechanical problems.

It was a chaotic scene the afternoon of November 13 at Union Square.

"The easiest way to make a conclusion when you can't find a mechanical cause is simply blame the driver," said Rob Cartwright Jr., tour bus driver's attorney.

PHOTOS: Several injuries reported after tour bus accident in SF

A double decker tour bus out of control careened down Post Street, hitting a bicyclist, cars, construction barricades and other objects, before crashing into scaffolding at Post and Stockton. In all 19 people were injured.

"He tried to put on the brakes. There were no brakes," said Cartwright Jr.

Today, San Francisco police announced they've finished investigating the crash. Their conclusion Kenneth Malvar may have mistaken the accelerator for the brakes when he tried to stop the runaway

"We have proof to show that the throttle was pressed and that we believe the brake was not pressed," said SF Police Sgt. Kevin Edison.

"To me that's absurd because I know my pedals on the vehicle," said Malvar.

Malvar, who has yet to recover from his injuries, says he's disappointed at the police report.

"I just want to state there was a mechanical problem on the bus," said Malvar.

RELATED: First look inside tour bus that crashed in SF's Union Square

The CHP's vaunted accident investigation team MAIT assisted in the probe.

"The vehicle was in fine working order. The steering worked, the brakes worked, the throttle worked," said CHP Public Information Officer Dan Hill.

Police today cited Malvar with driving at an unsafe speed.

"We approximated his speed above 40 mph, speed limit is 25 miles an hour," said SF Police Dept. Cmdr. Ann Mannix.

Cartwright would like to use his own specialists to examine the bus, but says investigators disassembled crucial parts of the vehicle during their probe. It's now impossible he says to reconstruct the bus to see if there was in fact a mechanical failure.

Related Topics:
newsbusbus accidentbus crashbus drivertourismcar crashcrashaccidentinvestigationtraffic accidentsan francisco countySan FranciscoUnion Square
(Copyright ©2016 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.)

Load Comments

More News

Top Stories
Show More