SF District Attorney Boudin says he believes SFPD investigations pact is salvageable

SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) -- San Francisco District Attorney Chesa Boudin publicly responded to Police Chief William Scott's announcement that his department is pulling out of an agreement that makes the DA's office the lead investigator for all police use-of-force incidents.

Boudin told reporters today that the agreement has worked in the past, believes it's salvageable, and would like to discuss it with Chief Scott.

If you're on the ABC7 News app, click here to watch live

"I'm confident that he will see that this team under my leadership has done things by the book, and there has been no prejudice to any investigation," Boudin said Thursday. "There's been no prejudice to any case, and to the extent there are any miscommunications, they are a normal back and forth of any MOU."

The MOU agreement dates back several years and was actually first introduced under then District Attorney George Gascon. Boudin renewed the agreement this past July.

SFPD's move comes as a department officer is scheduled to stand trial next week for allegedly beating a man with a baton while responding to a domestic violence call back in 2019.

RELATED: Man shot, killed in SFO police shooting told officers his gun was loaded, SFPD says

Last month, a DA investigator involved with the case testified that she allegedly felt pressure to withhold evidence.

Stephanie Sierra: "We have the opportunity to hear from you now about the fact that someone in your own office did testify they were pressured to withhold evidence. So that should concern you...what are you going to do about it now?"
Chesa Boudin: "I want to be clear I can't comment on any potential pending HR issues and I need to know what happened, because if someone in my office is pressured to do something that's improper...that's not acceptable. And whoever pressured them has to be held accountable."

VIDEO: New bill pressures SFPD, DA to release more data on domestic violence cases
EMBED More News Videos

A bill that aims to put pressure on SFPD and the San Francisco DA's office to release more data on domestic violence cases moved forward in committee.



Boudin defended the agreement repeatedly stating it has worked in the past.

"I want to be really clear, it was working," Boudin said.

The San Francisco District Attorney's Office said there were 14 fatal shootings from 2015 to 2018. But since the MOU agreement was signed in 2019, Boudin stressed police killings have gone down 'dramatically.'

"2019 was the first year that there were no fatal police uses of force and in 2020 and 2021 there was a single use of force incident each year," he said.

But Chief Scott responded saying the DA's office has been 'systematically violating the MOU terms' and the decision to terminate the agreement is based on the sworn testimony from a DA investigator last week. The DA investigator testified in open court she was pressured to mislead police about the status of a criminal investigation.

RELATED: San Francisco DA files homicide charges against officer in death of man shot in 2017

If you ask Boudin--that testimony predates his time as DA.

Stephanie Sierra: "Regardless of whether this predated your time or not... Are you actively working to figure out what exactly happened in this particular case?"
Chesa Boudin: "Absolutely, I'm not aware of one iota of evidence ... not an email... not a documented conversation, nothing that occurred during my tenure... that could possibly suggest that it is ever acceptable to be less than 100% truthful."

Yet, Chief Scott said the DA's office continues to be in violation of the agreement stating: "It has failed to respond to multiple requests from SFPD investigators to take part in ancillary criminal investigations, as the MOU requires."

Chief Scott said he stands by his decision.

RELATED: San Francisco police officer involved in Subway shooting also shot man in January, source says

But Boudin remains confident they'll work it out.

"I'm confident that he will see - this team - under my leadership has done things by the book," said Boudin.

The DA's office released a statement saying in part, "It is disappointing but no coincidence SFPD chose to withdraw from this agreement during the first-ever trial against of an on-duty San Francisco police officer for an unlawful beating."

The termination is set to take effect in 2 weeks.

Chief Scott has reached out to California Attorney General Rob Bonta's office to seek guidance on possible options for alternatives, but has yet to hear back.
Copyright © 2022 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.