EDD estimates nearly $20 billion paid to fraudsters since start of pandemic

Assembly Member Jim Patterson suspects scammers are trying to use his office in some of these potential EDD fraud schemes.

Jessica Harrington Image
Saturday, February 5, 2022
Scammers tried to use Assemblyman's office in EDD fraud scheme
The California Employment Development Department (EDD) estimates nearly $20 billion have been paid to fraudsters since the start of the pandemic.

FRESNO, Calif. -- The California Employment Development Department (EDD) estimates nearly $20 billion have been paid to fraudsters since the start of the pandemic.

That number is actually down from the $31 billion reported last year.

The EDD says it was an anomaly, but our sister station KFSN-TV in Fresno has discovered potential fraud is still happening.

The California EDD tightened its belt in 2020 after California district attorneys discovered billions of dollars in fraudulent payments were issued, including to inmates across the state.

Now Streaming 24/7 Click Here

If you're on the ABC7 News app, click here to watch live

"It is perhaps and will be, one of the biggest fraud of taxpayer dollars in California history," said Sacramento County District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert in a December 2020 press conference.

Shortly after, the EDD boasted a new task force that worked closely with EDD, "to employ new tools and bolster existing programs to strengthen its fraud detection methods to validate people's identities."

People were required to upload two primary forms of IDs such as a passport, driver's license, or military ID or one primary form and two secondary forms such as a phone bill, cable bill, or bank statement no more than 90 days old.

The new process left thousands of legitimate people who were out of work also out of money.

VIDEO: EDD offices have been closed to the public for over 25 years; here's why

The offices of the Employment Development Department didn't shut down because of the pandemic -- they've been closed for more than 25 years.

So many people were having issues uploading their verification documents that state representatives, like assembly member Jim Patterson, were allowed to step in to help.

Constituents could send their documents to Patterson's office, and staff would help upload them into the EDD's portal.

From there, the EDD and ID Me would begin the normal process of verification.

"Our staff has gotten very good at unwinding the problems and getting them fixed," Patterson said.

He says his office was able to help upwards of 3,000 people get the benefits they needed.

RELATED: New study finds millions of California workers are 'functionally unemployed'

Then one day, office staff suspected someone trying to upload their documents was attempting to commit fraud.

Patterson says an individual submitted their primary form of identification and a Credit One bank statement to be uploaded to the system.

Once they were processed and approved, the same person asked Patterson's office to help a friend.

That friend submitted their primary form of identification and what was supposed to be their Credit One bank statement.

But office staff looked closely and noticed the two people appeared to submit the same bank statement. Everything was identical from the charges on their account to the account number listed.

The only thing that was different was their name and address.

RELATED: EDD admits to waiting on man's unemployment claim so long, it was rejected

"When we discovered the fraud we were upset about it then we kind of laughed about, well, they're actually trying to use members of the legislatures office who are trying to help our constituents help them defraud the EDD." Patterson said.

Patterson's office immediately flagged the accounts as possible fraud with the EDD and reported it to law enforcement.

ABC7 News is not showing the names or identifying documents because the individuals have not been charged with a crime.

RELATED: Congress urged not to make unemployed workers pay back pandemic overpayments

EDD spokesperson Loree Levy says the department's fraud detection has been improved since 2020, saying the EDD believes it has stopped billions of dollars in potential fraud.

"Just because some fake documents are uploaded doesn't mean they result in payment either. We've seen a lot of fake documents," said California Employment Development Department Spokesperson Loree Levy.

But according to information provided to ABC7's sister station Action News, at least one of those individuals appears to have been paid tens of thousands of dollars.

Action News asked ID.me if its technology cold detect phony bills and banks statements, turns out it can't.

In a statement, ID.me's CEO and Founder Blake Hall said in part,

"ID.me has advanced capabilities to authenticate documents using machine vision and machine learning algorithms for photo government IDs. Documents like phone bills and bank statements are harder to verify as those documents don't have security features. However, the video chat verification is recorded so in the event of identity theft or fraud, there is an audit trail available to agencies."=

"Since they're basically saying they don't have a for sure way to detect those fake bills, is this still the best form of verification for individuals?" Action News reporter Jessica Harrington asked Levy.

VIDEO: Bay Area man loses all his benefits after returning EDD overpayment

A San Anselmo man tried to do right thing and return his overpayment money to EDD. He ended up losing all his benefits instead.

"Well, it's not all on its own. We do look at a combination of documents, it can't just be limited to a bill, for instance, a utility bill. So there are numerous things and I can't go into too many details, but there are numerous things that we look at in combination," Levy said.

Fresno County District Attorney Lisa Smittcamp says there are multiple ongoing EDD fraud investigations happening locally.

She says the cases are extremely difficult and time consuming to investigate and, likely, the punishment will be minimal, given California law.

"To try to get these people, you know the person who is doing a $5,000 claim or $10,000 claim, to jail or prison is probably going to be nearly impossible." Smittcamp said.

Smittcamp says taxpayers are the victims in all of this -- saying the saddest part is likely most of the money will never be recovered.

Smittcamp had this message for the alleged criminals and those thinking they can get away with something similar, "Just do the right thing and get a job."