Family and friends of both Sierra and Antolin Garcia-Torres, who pleaded not guilty to the murder charge, gathered in the Santa Clara County Courthouse Tuesday tensely awaiting the verdict.
Garcia-Torres faced four felony counts: count 1 for the murder and kidnap of the teen, and three additional counts for the attempted kidnapping of three adult women in the parking lots of two Safeway stores in Morgan Hill, where Garcia-Torres once worked.
Jurors found Garcia-Torres guilty on all four counts.
It was the outcome that Sierra's parents said they had wanted. The family emerged from the courthouse, willing to share the emotions for the first time after the 13-week trial. "We're grateful to the jurors coming up with the right decision, and it gives us peace as a family knowing that this is not going to happen to another child and that they can't get away with something like this," Sierra's mother, Marlene LaMar, said.
"Justice is served here for us today, justice for Sierra. That gives us some form of relief," Sierra's father, Steve LaMar, said. Sierra's sister, Danielle, said, "Obviously we'll never get Sierra back, so it's not closure, but it is a good first step. And the jury did the right thing."
Sentencing begins May 16. Jurors will have to decide whether Garcia-Torres will spend life in prison without the possibility of parole or face the death penalty.
Prosecutor David Boyd had a difficult case to convince the jury that Garcia-Torres was guilty, when there was no body, no murder weapon and no crime scene. Boyd was measured in his comments because the penalty phase of the case is still ahead. "We now move immediately into the next phase, the penalty phase where the jury will decide whether the defendant gets the death penalty or life without the possibility of parole. I'm not going to speculate just what the jury will do, it's their decision and it's a very significant one to be made," Boyd said.
VIDEO: Sierra LaMar's family speaks after verdict announced
Deliberations among the jury of six women and six men lasted the equivalent of two days. Judge Vanessa Zecher turned the case over to them May 4, after three months of testimony and arguments.
Sierra's family has been waiting five years for justice. She disappeared the morning of March 16, 2012, as she walked to the bus, and hasn't been seen or heard from since.
While no body, no crime scene and no murder weapon has ever been found, the prosecution relied on DNA evidence to connect Garcia-Torres, 26, to Sierra's disappearance. The teen's clothing and cell phone were found discarded near her family's home in the days after.
TIMELINE: Sierra LaMar kidnapping, murder case
The prosecution said Garcia-Torres' DNA was found on Sierra's jeans, and her DNA was found on an armrest in the defendant's red VW Jetta. In addition to that, a rope was also found in the trunk that the prosecution said had Sierra's hair. The defense, however, said the DNA evidence was flawed.
The defense also criticized investigators for not pursing all leads, including a brown car that was seen near the spot where Sierra may have disappeared.
The defense attorney concluded by saying: "Where's the evidence she's deceased? She is missing and nothing else."
"We felt very confident about the evidence that we had," Boyd said.
More than 100 members of the public attended Tuesday morning's verdict reading, requiring the courthouse to provide a live stream of the proceedings in a second courtroom, according to our news partner Bay City News.
This was an emotional day for volunteers, who searched for Sierra and who sat through many days of a 13-week-long trial to show their support to the LaMar family. One of them has a special place in his heart for Sierra. "Sierra is everybody's daughter. She's become our daughter. She's made a big impact on all of us, she's brought us together," volunteer search leader Douglas Tollis said.
RELATED: Sierra LaMar kidnapping had deep impact on Morgan Hill
Tollis said the search for Sierra is not over and he's hoping that Garcia-Torres during the penalty phase might reveal where her body is.
The penalty phase is not expected to be a quick process as both the defense and prosecution will be given the opportunity to tell the jury why they believe Garcia-Torres should or should not be given life in prison, without the possibility of parole or the death sentence. That process could take up to a month.
Click here for full coverage on Sierra LaMar and click here to follow David Louie for the very latest updates live from the courthouse.
ABC7 News brought you live coverage on TV and online after the verdict was announced. Click here to download the ABC7 News app for free. And be sure to enable push alerts to be the first to know about breaking news.