A look at Mayor Pete Buttigieg's fight to win the moderate vote in California -- Chasing California 2020

ByLiz Kreutz and Silvio Carillo KGO logo
Friday, February 21, 2020
Pete Buttigieg's fight to win the moderate vote in CA
In this episode of Chasing California 2020, ABC7 went one-on-one with Mayor Pete Buttigieg to discuss the challenges he faces trying to win the split moderate vote.

SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) -- After strong finishes in Iowa and New Hampshire, Mayor Pete Buttigieg is seeing momentum in his campaign and he's now turning his sights on California.

The South Bend, Indiana, mayor recently campaigned in Sacramento and Turlock, where he made his pitch to moderate voters -- many of whom said they were seeking an alternative to current front runner Bernie Sanders.

CHASING CALIFORNIA 2020: ABC7 Original Limited Series about political fight for California

"Here's what I'm offering: A way to make sure that we deliver real solutions that can get done, that are bold and progressive, but not divisive," Buttigieg told ABC7 News in a one-on-one interview after his Sacramento rally. "It's time to leave the politics of the past in the past."

The challenge? The moderate vote remains split among likely voters.

According to a Public Policy Institute of California poll released this week, Buttigieg is in a near four-way tie for second place in the California primary. Sanders is in the lead with support from 32% of likely voters, followed by Joe Biden (14%), Elizabeth Warren (13%) and then Michael Bloomberg and Buttigieg (both 12%).

CHASING CALIFORNIA 2020: Bernie Sanders' strategy to win California's Latino vote

"Broadly speaking, it does sort of seem like the progressive wing of the party is coalescing behind Bernie Sanders, and the moderates are kind of looking for somebody they can unify behind," Jeremy White, politics reporter and co-author of POLITCO California Playbook, explained. "I think Buttigieg also sees California as a big state and thinks there are a lot of those more moderate voters that he has a chance to appeal to."

Like Sanders and Bloomberg, Buttigieg's strategy in California has been to focus on often neglected parts of the state. Buttigieg, Sanders and Bloomberg, for instance, are the only candidates in the race who have campaigned in California's Central Valley.

But Buttigieg -- who has 16 staffers in California -- still lags behind Sanders and Bloomberg in presence. Sanders has 100 staff members in the state; Bloomberg has spent millions on ads.

"I don't have the personal fortune of a billionaire or the email list you'd have if you've run for president before, and yet we have been able to go from nothing over the course of the last year to have success in the first two states," Buttigieg told ABC7. "And I believe we can do the same here in California."

CHASING CALIFORNIA: Here's how unaffiliated voters could influence outcome of primary

A challenge for Buttigieg is his support among minority voters. According to a recent Quinnipiac poll, Buttigieg has 4% support from African American likely voters.

Tiffany Simms, an African American voter who attended Buttigieg's Sacramento town hall, said she is deciding between the moderate candidates and has some concerns about Buttigieg.

"I don't know that he's specifically addressing some concerns that are important to us," Simms said. "I mean, we still keep an open mind. There's no perfect candidate, but I would like to see him address some of those issues."

Asked about this concern, Buttigieg said he's still relatively unknown among black voters.

CHASING CALIFORNIA: Why climate change matters in Democratic Primary

"I think a lot of black voters and voters of color want to have a sense that they know you and it can take years to earn that trust," Buttigieg said. "Obviously, I'm a little newer to the scene, but I welcome the challenge and the responsibility of reaching out to voters of color and making sure they see themselves not just in how this campaign is built, but in where we seek to take the country."

Even among California mayors, the moderate vote is split. For instance, Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg supports Joe Biden. The West Sacramento Mayor Christopher Cabaldon supports Buttigieg.

Michele Bosco is a Buttigieg supporter who attended his rally in Sacramento alongside her friend, Michelle Forbes, who is undecided.

"I don't want the same old, same old," Bosco said. "I don't want another old white guy as president. I'm sick of the old white guys that's there now and I just think we need some change."

Forbes then chimed in with her opinion.

CHASING CALIFORNIA 2020: How former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg is courting California voters

"I am, what I consider moderate or center left, so for me Buttigieg is one of the options. Amy Klobuchar is also one of my options," she said. "I'm concerned about if we go too far to the left progressive."

Both Bosco and Forbes said they're concerned their vote for a moderate candidate will get split up.

"If we don't start having candidates get out of the race to make more room for that upfront candidate, so that we're not splitting up the moderate vote," Forbes said. "That's crucial."

Chasing California is an ABC7 Original Limited Series about the political fight for California.

Now more than ever, California votes will matter in determining the presidential nominee.

And stuff's about to get real.

The "Move to March" pushed the primary into the Super Tuesday mix--raising the stakes for the nation's most populous state. Now going into Super Tuesday, hundreds of delegates and millions of dollars are up for grabs. The Democratic nominee is undecided and unaffiliated and first-time voters are flexing their power. So, how do candidates harness that power? What lengths will they go to capture those golden votes in the 2020 California Primary?

See more Chasing California stories here.

See more stories and videos about Building a Better Bay Area here.