Stanley Roberts, professor explain psychology behind recent videos showing people behaving badly

Wayne Freedman Image
ByWayne Freedman KGO logo
Thursday, July 9, 2020
Experts talk psychology behind recent videos showing people behaving badly
Americans have been subjected to and been fascinated by what has become an almost daily parade of people behaving badly, all caught on camera. We talked to Stanley Roberts and a Bay Area professor who explained the psychology behind the videos.

SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) -- In the last few weeks, Americans have been subjected to and been fascinated by what has become an almost daily parade of, well, let's be kind and just refer to them as extremely bad moments, all caught on camera.

If we watched only the videos, it would seem that our world is full of entitled, white, Karens or Kens shouting, "All lives matter!" and telling people of Asian ancestry, "Go home. You don't belong here."

EXCLUSIVE: Waitress who stopped SF tech CEO's racist rant at Carmel Valley restaurant shares what happened

Waitress Gennica Cochran, who stopped Solid8 CEO Michael Lofthouse's racist rant at Carmel Valley restaurant, spoke exclusively to ABC7 News on "what needed to be done" and is now urging others to do the same.

Have you wondered what is happening here? With the stress of a pandemic, is this behavior becoming more widespread?

"I think it's the fact that we have cameras everywhere," said Dr. Thomas Plante, a professor of psychology at Santa Clara University. "There are a lot of people who are tense and frustrated and a lot of them have a short fuse. Small incidents set them off."

"Think before you speak. My mom taught me that a long time ago," said reporter Stanley Roberts, who made a franchise of catching people in the act of behaving badly. "A long time ago we had people with pitchforks and fire trying to get people who were bad. Now we have cell phones."

RELATED: What motivates a 'Karen'? Experts weigh in on popular term

Any presumption of privacy is now long gone. So, we asked why people seen to dig themselves in even deeper when they know multiple cameras may be watching every move and recording every word?

"It is really hard for a lot of people, once they get launched, to dial back, take a deep breath, and say hold it here," said Dr. Plante. "We need to appeal to our inner angels."

"They are trying to defend their position but it just puts them in a deeper hole!" added Roberts. "People don't realize that once a camera is rolling, it does not discriminate. It will roll for everything."

FULL VIDEO: SF Man says white couple called police for stenciling 'Black Lives Matter' on his property

James Juanillo, who identifies as a person of color, posted a video to Twitter Friday showing his encounter with a white couple who called the police after they saw him stenciling "black lives matter" onto his own property.

Now, with the internet, those small cameras have world-wide influence when, rightly or wrongly, we see bad behavior publicly pilloried and vilified. It is human nature that when some of us see those videos, we feel so much more virtuous.

"There is no due process anymore. Just mob mentality," said Dr. Plante. "There is a diffusion of responsibility when you're alone and anonymous on your computer. You can say remarkable things online and there is no consequence."

Such episodes can live online forever. Often, they lead to job firings and even death threats. Do they serve a greater good?

"This is a way to get out what we knew was going on but couldn't prove it," said Roberts. "We used to say they were racist, but it is better to show the video."

EXCLUSIVE: Bay Area man speaks out after former 24 Hour Fitness exec told his family 'you can't be in this country'

An Asian American family from the East Bay is processing the events that happened while on a hike near Mt. Tam on July 4th, when a woman confronted them and told them repeatedly they "can't be in this country."

So now we have it. If George Orwell was still around, he might say that he warned us.

Welcome to the 21st century.

RELATED: San Francisco supervisor introduces 'CAREN' Act to outlaw racially motivated 911 calls

With so many cameras around, better be ready for your close-up.